The Outrage Only Runs One Way
THROWING ROCKS AT SUCCESS • Part 4 of 5
Outrage for Some, a Pass for Others
Herbert Roberts, P.E.
A check valve lets flow pass in one direction and slams shut against the other. Public outrage at builders works the same way.
Throwing rocks at innovators is not a new trend. The rocks usually carry a grain of fact, and the grain gets sold as the whole stone.
In January 1914, Henry Ford doubled his minimum pay to $5 a day. The Wall Street Journal answered that doubling the wage “without regard to length of service, is to apply Biblical or spiritual principles into a field where they do not belong,” and said Ford had “committed economic blunders, if not crimes.” Ten thousand men lined up at the Ford employment office within a day.
Eight years before that, the Paris edition of the New York Herald looked at two bicycle makers from Dayton and wrote that the Wrights “are in fact either fliers or liars.” They were fliers.
The pattern holds today. Edison “stole the light bulb.” Jobs “stole from Xerox” and “stole from Woz.” Each one has a grain of history in it, and each one gets told as the whole story.
Right and wrong at the same time
Part 1 covered Edison and Swan. Here is the part of that story most people miss. I am the inventor of record on 70 U.S. patents covering engine repair, composite parts, and coatings, and hundreds of variations on a core idea are patentable. So you can point to a dozen people with a light bulb patent and be right and wrong at the same time about who “invented” it. Edison’s own U.S. Patent 223,898, granted January 27, 1880, covered one carbon-filament lamp in a vacuum bulb. In 1883, Edison’s and Swan’s British companies merged into the Edison and Swan United Electric Light Company. They settled it in business, not in a comment section.
The word “practical” never appears in the test. A U.S. patent asks three questions: is it new, is it useful, and is it non-obvious to someone skilled in the field (35 U.S.C. 101, 102, and 103). Practical gets decided later, by people buying and using a working product. You can be the third inventor and still have the far more successful product.
Jobs and PARC follow the same script. In 1979, Xerox’s venture arm bought 100,000 shares of pre-IPO Apple for about $1 million, and in return Apple got its look inside the lab. Xerox made the deal and got the shares. The “theft” was a negotiated trade.
Woz is the one sore spot with real feeling in it. Jobs told him Atari paid $700 for the Breakout design and split it; Woz later read that Jobs got a $5,000 bonus. “I cried,” Woz said, and “I just wish he had been honest.” That hurt is real. The critics took that one sore spot and made it the whole story, while Woz stayed Jobs’s friend and kept defending him for decades.
The pushers
Every one of these stories has the same two roles. One person makes the prototype. Another is a pusher, the one who drags that prototype to the factory and the cash register.
Woz built a beautiful machine. In his own words: “I never wanted to run a company. I didn’t want to worry about money. I didn’t want to move up the management chain. I wanted to be an engineer for life.” Every time he designed something great, he said, Jobs would say, “Let’s sell it.”
Tesla is the modern version. Part 1 told the founding story. Eberhard was replaced as CEO in August 2007 as the Roadster ran late and over budget. In 2010, Tesla bought the Fremont plant. In 2024 alone, it delivered 1,789,226 vehicles.
Woz, by his own account, never wanted to make the push from prototype to factory. Eberhard did want a company, and he had built and sold one before. But wanting a company and pushing a car through a factory are two different climbs.
Many never push past the prototype. The ones that do, and sell thousands, earn the practical stamp of public approval.
The public lore is hard on the pushers. But without them, the product most likely would have had a lesser outcome. So the complaint that someone was not first, or was “just an investor,” misses the point.
People often overlook the innovation in their own hands. Before you congratulate yourself on a great PowerPoint slide, remember who made it possible. Douglas Engelbart built the first mouse in the 1960s. The keyboard layout traces back to Christopher Sholes’s typewriter in the 1870s. IBM put the personal computer on office desks in 1981. RCA’s labs pioneered the liquid crystal display that became your flat screen. And PowerPoint itself started at a small company called Forethought before Microsoft bought it in 1987. Someone invented every one of them, and someone else built them by the millions.
Each one was an advancement, and most made money for one or more people along the way. None of that money was stolen from the masses. It was paid, one purchase at a time, by millions of people who wanted the thing badly enough to buy it. Nobody was forced. There was always the option to go without, or to choose a different tool. The alternative to Amazon is a trip to the store. Banks and universities that now expect you to own a phone and a computer are not in collusion with the builders. They made the same choice everyone else did, because the tools work better than what came before.
Any new technology has both good and bad effects on the status quo. But as Noriaki Kano showed, a feature that delights customers today becomes one they expect tomorrow. The phone went from a delighter to a must-have in a single generation.
Not a fluke
All three men had a before. Musk built Zip2, sold to Compaq in 1999 for $307 million, and then X.com, which became PayPal and sold to eBay in 2002 for $1.5 billion. Jobs and Woz sold “blue boxes” for free long-distance calls, at $150 apiece door to door in the Berkeley dorms. Jobs later said that without the blue boxes, there would have been no Apple. Eberhard co-founded NuvoMedia, maker of the Rocket eBook, and sold it to Gemstar in 2000 for a reported $187 million.
Only two of them had an after. Jobs went on to NeXT, Pixar, the iPod, and the iPhone. Musk went on to SpaceX, Tesla at scale, Starlink, Neuralink, The Boring Company, and xAI. In January 2024, Neuralink implanted its first human patient, Noland Arbaugh, who went on to move a cursor and play online chess with his thoughts. Eberhard had a real history, just not an after on that scale.
Looking at Musk’s record, Tesla was not a fluke never to be repeated.
Greedy criminals and public law
The valve really shows when the crowd calls the rich greedy criminals.
The tax code is public law, printed for anyone to read. Congress writes it, and under Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution, every bill for raising revenue has to start in the House. Following that law is not a crime. Using a rule Congress wrote on purpose is not a loophole. It is the design.
Four rules draw most of the anger, and every one of them is on the books by a vote.
*Carried interest.* Fund managers pay capital-gains rates, not wage rates, on their share of a fund’s profits. Critics in both parties have called it a loophole for decades.
*The step-up in basis.* When someone dies, their heirs value inherited stock or land at its price on the day of death. Nobody ever pays income tax on the gain built up during the owner’s lifetime. Estates above $15 million per person can still owe estate tax. The 2025 tax law left the step-up intact.
*The pass-through deduction.* Owners of partnerships, S corporations, and other pass-through businesses can deduct up to 20 percent of their business income. It was set to expire after 2025. Congress made it permanent.
*Qualified small business stock.* Founders and early investors in a qualifying startup can exclude much of their gain when they sell. In 2025, Congress raised the cap from $10 million to $15 million per company. Partial exclusions now start after three years, and the full exclusion comes at five.
That last one deserves a second look. Congress wrote a rule that rewards exactly the people this series defends: the ones who put money into a company before it had a product. Whatever you think of it, nobody snuck it in. It passed in the open, and it got bigger.
Any member of the House can introduce a bill to change any of these, twenty years ago or tomorrow. So ask your congressperson to write one. I am sure it will be a top priority.
Stock rich is not cash rich
The net worth in the headline is mostly stock, and stock is not cash. A founder’s fortune is a share of a company, priced by what the last buyer paid for the last share. It does not buy groceries until someone sells it.
At a startup, often nobody can sell it. Before a company goes public or gets bought, there is usually no market for its shares at all. Employees who hold options pay real cash to exercise them, and exercising can trigger a tax bill on a gain they cannot sell. Plenty of startup paper fortunes ended at zero.
Selling costs something even after the company grows. Every share a founder sells gives up a piece of control, and a large sale can push the price down. In late 2021, Musk sold about $14 billion of Tesla stock, much of it to cover the tax on options that were about to expire. He takes no cash salary from Tesla. His only way to pay a tax bill is to sell stock. His last sales came in about 11 percent below the stock’s record close, and he said he would pay more than $11 billion in taxes that year.
The critics have a fair point here. The stock-rich can borrow against their shares, live on the loans, and never sell. Add the step-up at death, and the gain may never be taxed as income. That is real, and it is printed law too, which brings us back to the valve.
Typed on an iPhone
While many people benefit from the convenience of the iPhone, a portion of its users openly protest its existence. “They exploit workers at the iPhone factory,” the post says, typed on an iPhone.
The history behind it is real. In 2010, 14 workers at Foxconn, Apple’s main assembler, died in suicide attempts. In 2012, the Fair Labor Association’s audit of three Foxconn plants found excessive hours and unpaid overtime. Foxconn had already raised many workers’ pay 16 to 25 percent that February and agreed to cut hours and pay back overtime. Watchdog groups kept reporting problems in later years, but the raise and the audit are the less-told part of the story. The charge travels fast. The follow-up rarely does.
The same goes for the dream of leaving it all behind. Going off-grid relies on technology that true pioneers only dreamed of. Utility-scale solar power fell about 90 percent in cost from 2010 to 2024, battery packs hit a record low of $115 per kilowatt-hour in 2024, and Starlink now serves more than 13 million subscribers, many of them where no cable ever reached. Ride-hailing and online banking don’t work in a cash-only, phone-free life either.
The check valve
A check valve has one job: let flow through in one direction and slam shut against the other. The crowd’s outrage is built the same way. It flows freely at the people who use the rule and stops cold at the people who write it.
Take the oldest target on the list. In 2016, both major-party nominees promised to end the carried-interest break. The 2017 tax law kept it and only stretched the holding period from one year to three. The 2025 tax law left it untouched. On April 16, 2026, a bill to end it went to the Senate Finance Committee, where it has had no further action. Two campaigns, two tax laws, and one bill later, the break both sides promised to kill is still in the code. The rock lands on whoever used the rule, and the people who write the rule get a pass. Following the law is not a crime.
---
Tuesday, Part 5: Trim the Tall Poppies, Starve the Field. The critics want to trim the tall poppies, and the tall poppies built the field.
Herbert Roberts, P.E. is a licensed professional engineer with 30+ years in aviation research and development across three companies, in addition to analyzing accidents under his P.E. license.
Sources
- American Heritage (archived), “Henry Ford’s Revolution for the Worker” (WSJ 1914 editorial quote): https://web.archive.org/web/20081006083637/americanheritage.com/events/articles/web/20060105-henry-ford-five-dollar-day-model-t-ford-motor-company-assembly-line-james-couzens-highland-park-detroit-automobiles.shtml
- New York Times, “The Economics of Henry Ford May Be Passé,” Apr. 5, 2006 (10,000 men in line): https://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/05/business/the-economics-of-henry-ford-may-be-passe.html
- Wright Brothers Aeroplane Co., “The Prize Patrol” (Paris Herald, Feb. 10, 1906): https://www.wright-brothers.org/History_Wing/Wright_Story/Showing_the_World/Prize_Patrol/Prize_Patrol.htm
- National Archives, Edison’s patent for the electric lamp (1880): https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/thomas-edisons-patent-application-for-the-light-bulb
- Google Patents, US223898A: https://patents.google.com/patent/US223898A/en
- Thomas A. Edison Papers, Rutgers, “Edison and Swan United Electric Light Company”: https://edison.rutgers.edu/life-of-edison/companies/company-details/electric-light,-foreign/edison-and-swan-united-electric-light-company-ltd
- 35 U.S.C. 101, 102, 103: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/35/101 ; https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/35/102 ; https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/35/103
- The New Yorker, Malcolm Gladwell, “Creation Myth,” May 16, 2011: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2011/05/16/creation-myth
- Computer History Museum, “Xerox PARC”: https://www.computerhistory.org/revolution/story/348
- The Telegraph, “Steve Wozniak: Steve Jobs’ deal made me cry,” Dec. 2011: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/8956282/Steve-Wozniak-Steve-Jobs-deal-made-me-cry.html
- eWeek, “Wozniak: I Wanted to be an Engineer for Life”: https://www.eweek.com/networking/wozniak-i-wanted-to-be-an-engineer-for-life/
- Los Angeles Times, “Tesla founders end bitter legal fight,” Sept. 22, 2009: https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2009-sep-22-fi-tesla22-story.html
- Tesla Form 8-K, Fremont (NUMMI) purchase, Oct. 2010: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000119312510232709/d8k.htm
- Tesla Investor Relations, Q4 2024 production and deliveries: https://ir.tesla.com/press-release/tesla-fourth-quarter-2024-production-deliveries-and-deployments
- Stanford Technology Ventures Program, Elon Musk (Zip2, PayPal): https://stvp.stanford.edu/people/elon-musk
- Computer History Museum, “Steve Jobs: From Garage to World’s Most Valuable Company” (blue boxes): https://computerhistory.org/blog/steve-jobs/
- Marc Tarpenning, Rocket (NuvoMedia sold for $187 million in 2000): https://marctarpenning.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Rocket_Marc_Tarpenning.pdf
- Federal Trade Commission, early termination notice, Gemstar / NuvoMedia, Jan. 4, 2000: https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/early-termination-notices/20001042
- Reuters, “Neuralink implants brain chip in first human,” Jan. 29, 2024: https://www.reuters.com/technology/neuralink-implants-brain-chip-first-human-musk-says-2024-01-29/
- Reuters, “Neuralink shows first brain-chip patient playing online chess,” Mar. 21, 2024: https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/neuralink-shows-first-brain-chip-patient-playing-online-chess-2024-03-21/
- Noriaki Kano et al., “Attractive Quality and Must-Be Quality,” Journal of the Japanese Society for Quality Control, 1984: [ADD URL]
- U.S. Constitution, Art. I, Sec. 7: https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/article-1/section-7/
- Commission on Presidential Debates, Oct. 9, 2016 transcript (carried interest): https://www.debates.org/voter-education/debate-transcripts/october-9-2016-debate-transcript/
- Pierce Atwood, “The One Big Beautiful Bill Act and Estate Planning” (step-up intact, Section 199A permanent): https://www.pierceatwood.com/alerts/one-big-beautiful-bill-act-and-estate-planning-what-you-need-know
- Foster Garvey, “One Big Beautiful Bill Act, Part V – Qualified Small Business Stock Exclusion”: https://www.foster.com/larry-s-tax-law/one-big-beautiful-bill-act-part-5-qualified-small-business-stock-exclusion-code-section-1202
- Nixon Peabody, “Business tax reform: Key changes under the OBBB Act” (QSBS holding periods): https://www.nixonpeabody.com/insights/alerts/2025/07/23/business-tax-reform-key-changes-under-the-obbb-act
- Foley & Lardner, OBBBA and the investment fund industry (estate exemption): https://www.foley.com/?p=114060
- CNBC, “Elon Musk says he will pay over $11 billion in taxes this year,” Dec. 20, 2021: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/12/20/elon-musk-says-he-will-pay-over-11-billion-in-taxes-this-year.html
- CNN via ABC7, “Elon Musk owes $11 billion in taxes after wrapping up his Tesla stock sales,” Dec. 29, 2021: https://abc7.com/does-elon-musk-pay-taxes-how-much-in-net-worth-tesla/11402993
- New York Times, “After Suicides, Scrutiny of China’s Grim Factories,” June 7, 2010: https://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/07/business/global/07suicide.html
- CNN Money, “Apple supplier audit finds major wage and overtime violations,” Mar. 29, 2012: https://money.cnn.com/2012/03/29/technology/apple-foxconn-report/index.htm
- New York Times, “Foxconn Plans to Lift Pay Sharply at Factories in China,” Feb. 2012: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/technology/foxconn-to-raise-salaries-for-workers-by-up-to-25.html
- IRENA, “Solar energy” (90% cost decline 2010 to 2024): https://www.irena.org/Energy%20Transition/Technology/Solar-energy
- BloombergNEF, battery pack prices fall to $115/kWh, Dec. 2024: https://about.bnef.com/insights/commodities/lithium-ion-battery-pack-prices-see-largest-drop-since-2017-falling-to-115-per-kilowatt-hour-bloombergnef/
- Fierce Network, “Starlink broadband marches onward with 1.6M new global subs in Q3” (13.6M subscribers): https://www.fierce-network.com/broadband/starlink-broadband-marches-onward-16m-new-global-subs-q3
- Fortune, “GOP tax bill preserves carried interest loophole,” May 23, 2025: https://fortune.com/2025/05/23/president-trump-tax-bill-carried-interest-private-equity-hedge-funds-venture-capital-house-senate/
- The Hedge Fund Journal, “One Big Beautiful Bill Act” (Section 1061 unchanged): https://thehedgefundjournal.com/one-big-beautiful-bill-act-private-funds-tax-implications/
- Congress.gov, S.4330, Ending the Carried Interest Loophole Act (introduced Apr. 16, 2026): https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/4330


